One case study of in-custody death: A 'perfect storm' of deadly errors

Small slips in tactics and making assumptions can quickly compound into calamity


Nothing sends a wake-up call about the importance of searching thoroughly like having a prisoner slash his throat in the backseat of your patrol car. Two Wisconsin deputies experienced that unnerving occurrence while transporting a mental patient to a treatment facility and ended up as defendants in a federal civil suit, accused of “deliberate indifference” to the victim’s right to life. For officers everywhere, this is a harsh reminder that small slips in tactics and making assumptions can quickly compound into a “perfect storm” of calamity.

Here’s what happened, according to court records and an exclusive interview with Robert Willis, a well-known law enforcement trainer and legal consultant hired by the deputies’ defense attorneys. As a courtesy to the officers involved, we’ve changed their names.

Login as verified officer to view full article

Please do NOT re-register if you are unable to login. Contact member support below.

Login Problems? If you have any problems with registration or login, or if you would like to inquire about your secure confirmation, please do not hesitate to contact us online. Please check out our FAQ page.

logo for print