If you received this newsletter from a friend, we welcome you to sign up to become a member.


PoliceOne Features

Law Enforcement News
Research Topics
Officer Safety Section
Get PoliceOne News

November 11, 2010

Editor's Note: The 1,000th 'Newsline'

When a cop throws a punch to the face

Experience the Street Survival Seminar

2010-2011 Street Survival Calendar


The 1,000th 'Newsline'

By Dave Smith, PoliceOne Contributor & Calibre Press Senior Instructor

Click to Print Article

For more than 30 years, Calibre Press has helped the law enforcement community remain healthy both emotionally and physically, and win encounters of every kind. A thousand Newlines ago Chuck Remsberg expanded his service to the crime fighting community by creating the first Newsline. It’s appropriate this Newsline be transmitted on Veteran’s Day — a day that America remembers the service of the millions of men and women who have served in our armed forces. So many of those heroes continue their service by putting on a badge and gun to protect our liberties here at home! We are so proud to be part of that mission by assisting you with training and information.

PoliceOne, Calibre Press, and the Street Survival Seminar exist to give you the resources you need to prepare yourself for whatever challenge you face. The philosophy of always having “When/Then” thinking is the driving force in our articles and videos. The real training has always been — and always will be — within you. You are the one who has to face the threats and stresses of our profession. You must craft your own mental and physical skills to meet whatever the street throws at you. While we provide tools to help you, it is your responsibility to keep your mind, skills, equipment, and body ready for the next mountain you’ll have to climb.

That’s why — whether or not you are a military veteran — you are our mission. This is your Newsline.  Your feedback guides the content. Tell us what you want to see, hear, and learn in the future and we will do our best to get it you. We look forward to hearing from each of you in the future — a future we hope to help make safer and better by continuing to grow as you do!

Stay safe.
— Dave Smith


When a cop throws a punch to the face

By Ed Flosi, PoliceOne Contributor

Click to Print Article

 In some situations it may be absolutely reasonable and appropriate for a law enforcement officer to strike a suspect in the head/face area with a fisted punch. To be clear, I am writing about a knuckles-leading-the-way punch. Using a fisted punch is a natural response that some have trained to do for many years through martial arts, boxing, or other fighting sports. It is true that under stress the dominant response will prevail so if the officer has spent many hours practicing fisted punches, he/she will most likely deliver fisted punches as a body weapon option when under stress. Others have “previous experience” in using fisted punches in other contexts.   

There are some downsides to striking a suspect in the head/face area with a fisted punch. The first and most concerning problem is the injury potential to the officer. People tend to punch with their dominant arm in order to get the most power into the strike. The problem with an officer using his/her dominant arm is that it is usually the weapon side arm as well. There is a high likelihood of injury when using a fisted strike including bone breaks and wrist injuries. It would be difficult for an officer to draw and fire his/her firearm with a severe injury to the weapon side hand.

Enhance Your Career with a Solid Understanding
of the Law

The Master of Science in Law degree at Champlain College is designed for students who seek an understanding of the law and the legal system.

• Flexible online programs that work around your busy schedule

• Financial aid available along with alternative funding

• Get your degree in only two and a half years

Contact an admissions advisor today

Champlain College

Another consideration should be the anger reaction that will result from a punch to the face. Remember the last time you were punched in the face? Were you a bit livid at the person throwing the punch? The resulting effect may be that the person will now fight even more strongly against your efforts to control him. In today’s society you are almost certain to get a complaint from a suspect that was punched in the face. We have to be honest with ourselves and realize that although you may not have the complaint sustained in the end, who really enjoys the process of being a subject officer in a complaint process? Also, a fisted strike may appear “brutal” and “thuggish” to witnesses who in today’s world expect officers to act as trained professionals.

There are viable options to a fisted strike that are less injurious to the officer. Using a palm-heel strike can generate a substantial amount of force while offering more protection from injury. The body mechanics are virtually the same but instead of using a fisted hand the officer uses the heel of palm as a striking surface. Another option would be to use a hammer fist (lower edge of fist used for pounding blows)1 strike.

Introducing the First True HD In-Car Video

WatchGuard 4RE is completely revolutionary because it eliminates the agonizing compromise between video quality and file size. The WatchGuard 4RE makes HD practical by giving agencies incredible image quality for the video that turns out to be important, while keeping the routine video (typically 90% of recordings) at a standard resolution.

Get this new technology for your dept.

WatchGuard Video

In choosing a force option, officers must be mindful of the level of the intrusion into the suspect’s 4th Amendment rights. A way of analyzing this intrusion would be to look at the expectation of injury to the suspect based on “how” the force option is being used. A blow of sufficient force with any personal body weapon to a head/face could result in serious bodily injury or could be fatal.

Serious injuries that could result from a fisted strike to the head/face include

  1. a blow to the face area could cause disfigurement
  2. a blow to the temple or to the skull at the junction of jaw and ear, possibly damaging major blood vessels
  3. a blow at the junction of head and neck, possibly severing the spinal cord2

This expectation of injury must be reasonably balanced with the governmental interests at stake, or the “why.” In Graham v Connor (490 U.S. 386 (1989)), the US Supreme Court gave law enforcement several factors to examine when evaluating the “why” of an officer’s force option including, but not limited to:

  1. the severity of crime at issue
  2. the threat of the suspect
  3. the level of resistance offered by the suspect

Other Product Categories
Tactical Headsets
Shooting Range Equipment

Visit the PoliceOne Products page

More Police Videos
Perspectives: Mark Dunston - Use of Force
PoliceOne Academy
Kevin Dillon: Armbar Manipulations

Visit PoliceOneTV

Knowing that purposely striking a person in the face with a fist (the “how”) may cause serious injury, the governmental interests (the “why”) must be of a more serious nature as well in order to create the reasonable balance as described in Graham.

Some trainers have observed an increase in officers using a fisted strike into the suspect’s face as a first response to any resistance. This may be a reasonable response if the officer can articulate the need for a more severe force response. Unfortunately in many of the cases being discussed the articulation is not enough to justify a “punch him in the face” response. This could be a function of different variables at play. The officer may have done a poor job in documenting the totality of the circumstances known to him/her at the time. In other cases, the officer may have received training that overemphasized punching drills in their defensive tactics training.

Trainers need to be aware that an overabundance of pugilistic3 training may have a negative end result. We are not training officers to stand toe-to-toe with a suspect to have a fair boxing match. Officers need to understand that they may have to resort to pure violence of action at any given moment in response to a life-threatening event. The use of body weapons is an important part of any defensive tactics training in order to teach officers to defend themselves and/or to create distance to transition to a better suited force option. The problem that can result from the overuse of pugilistic training is that the trainer is reinforcing the use of a fisted strike. This brings into play all the listed problems above, instead of other law enforcement solutions.

1California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, Learning Domain 33 (Arrest Methods/Defensive Tactics)
2California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, Learning Domain 33 (Arrest Methods/Defensive Tactics)
3Pugilism is the skill, practice, and sport of fighting with the fists; boxing (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Pugilistic).

Watch the new Calibre Press Video to experience the Street Survival Seminar firsthand.

Meet the Calibre Press Instructors:

Senior Instructor Dave "Buck Savage" Smith
Sgt. Raimondo "Ray" DeCunto
Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith

Sponsored by:
U.S. Armor

Seminar Location Dates Seminar Info.
Street Survival Seminar
Lancaster, SC
November 18-19, 2010
Street Survival Seminar
Scottsdale, AZ
November 30-31, 2010
Street Survival Seminar - PoliceOne Member Event
Las Vegas, NV
December 8-9, 2010
Street Survival Seminar
Deer Park, TX
December 14-15, 2010
Street Survival Seminar
Atlanta, GA
January 25-26, 2011
Street Survival Seminar
Atlantic City, NJ
February 9-10, 2011
Street Survival Seminar
Las Vegas, NV (Women's)
February 16-17, 2011
Street Survival Seminar
Daytona Beach, FL
February 22-23, 2011

The Street Survival Seminar is GSA Approved! Our training contract number is GS-07F-0175W.

Click here to view the full 2010-2011 Seminar Schedule.

Calibre Press now also offers the following customizable training courses:

  • Street Survival
  • Street Survival for Women
  • Leadership: Street Survival for Executives

Please contact Fred Hirschler at Fred.Hirschler@calibrepress.com to find out how you can bring a Calibre Press course to your department.

Questions, comments, suggestions about this Newsline?

E-mail us at editor@policeone.com.

Network with CalibrePress Street Survival Seminar

PoliceOne.com Calibre Press BLUtube PoliceOneTV PoliceGrantsHelp.com PoliceOne Books

(c) 2010: PoliceOne. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Sign up for the PoliceOne Newsletter