The crucial role of the decoy in K-9 training

Ed. Note: This article is adapted from the Jerry Bradshaw’s upcoming book, Controlled Aggression in Theory & Practice, available from the Tarheel Canine Pro Shop and is reprinted by permission of the author.


It used to be thought that to decoy for a police dog required no previous training or instruction, other than choosing a guy who had no fear of dogs. Get a guy to suit up, tell him to run, and send the dog! Those days have to be over if we are to progress our dogs in their patrol work.

Now, we realize, that is a poor way to train your dog. The decoy is the reward mechanism for your dog's patrol training, and so we need someone in the suit who can read the dog, and reward him with a grip appropriately, to increase the likelihood of all the critical behaviors the dog must master in the patrol phase.

A good decoy can go a long way to improving a dog's performance. Every training session is loaded with behavioral feedback to the dog. The decoy is the one in control of that feedback. Would you allow an untrained person to work your dog in obedience, or handle him in tracking? When you use an unskilled decoy you are doing exactly that. The decoy trains the dog in patrol work. Behaviors shown by the dog are either rewarded properly or not, and if we do not reward the dog for releasing, or coming back on a recalled attack, for example, we run the risk of seeing these behaviors deteriorate as the dog makes his own reward system by taking dirty grips or running through his recalls.

Proper timing, mechanics of catching the dog to avoid jams, technique to catch dogs in the front of the suit (not all bad guys are running away) on more confrontational bites, how to push the dog in defense and then relieve the pressure to improve the dogs ability to channel drives - these are some of the skills the decoy must learn.

Look at the four quadrants of operant conditioning below, known as the "Consequences of Behavior," and the associated examples of how the decoy, through his actions is the instrument we use to condition the dog during patrol training.

The Consequences of Behavior
The probability of a behavior recurring is affected by the consequences of the behavior itself. We speak of two consequences: Reinforcement (a reinforcing consequence is one that will increase the frequency of a behavior) and Punishment (a punishing consequence is one that will decrease the frequency of a behavior). Now, both reinforcement and punishment can be either positive or negative, thus we have four consequences we must define:

Positive Reinforcement: A particular behavior is strengthened due to a desirable consequence. For example a dog barks aggressively after the alert command is given, and receives a grip as a reward, increasing the likelihood he will bark when we alert him.

Negative Reinforcement: Eliminating some undesirable consequence strengthens a particular behavior. For example, in training the out with a difficult dog, we pull tight on the pinch collar (rather than making a correction) or choke collar, applying pressure, and when the dog outs, we relieve the pressure.

Negative Punishment: Withholding the reinforcing consequence weakens a particular behavior. For example, the dog stops barking in the hold and bark exercise for find and bark training. The handler snatches the dog back with the long line, and the decoy escapes out of sight. The dog is re-sent to the decoy, and the reward grip is withheld in this manner until the dog barks continuously.

Positive Punishment: A particular behavior is weakened by the presentation of an unpleasant consequence. For example, the dog wants to run out of a down command to the bite before we give the send command, so we apply a correction for the down, and send him only when he is holding the down properly. The same can be done with eye contact, heeling around decoys, sitting around decoys to enhance control over your dog when he is in "bite mode."

It is critical that decoys, handlers and trainers understand these consequences of behavior and how to apply them. Good decoys know when to apply each consequence, and why.


If your decoy skills and dog reading could use a boost, contact TK9 to schedule to attend one of our decoy seminars.



About the author

Girard William “Jerry” Bradshaw is the CEO and Training Director for Tarheel Canine Training, Inc. of Sanford, North Carolina. Jerry is a professional consultant to various Police agencies and private corporations for K9 training & deployment. Jerry is often featured speaker at Police K9 conferences and has been invited to instruct at workshops and seminars around the country. Jerry has written articles for Dog Sport Magazine and Police K9 Magazine, and is the author of the forthcoming book Controlled Aggression in Theory & Practice, which is available for purchase here.

Jerry is a co-founder, Judge, and East Coast Director of one of the fastest growing protection dog sports in America, widely recognized as the single most difficult protection sport there is, PSA. Jerry is also a co-founding director of the National Tactical Police Dog Association which applies many of the same successful scenario-based principles found in PSA to the certification of police dogs.

Jerry has competed in National Championship trials in both Schutzhund and PSA, winning the PSA national championships in 2003 with his dog Ricardo V.D. Naaturzicht. Jerry is the only competitor to train 2 dogs to the PSA 3 level, and has achieved the SchH 3 level numerous times, with “V” scores. Tarheel Canine Training is a nationally renowned training facility for police service dogs, and has placed trained police dogs at various federal, state, and local agencies nationally and internationally since 1994. For more information on Tarheel Canine Training, or Jerry Bradshaw, please click here.

Jerry’s latest book, Controlled Aggression in Theory & Practice, was written for police K9 professionals and covers basic foundation training such as testing green K9 prospects for patrol suitability, training drive development, drive channeling, working in the bite suit, human orientation (combating equipment orientation). The book further features key skills training including training guarding behavior, out on command, redirected bites and the out and return, and the best way to train a call off with little to no pressure on the dog. If you have trouble with the recall (call-off) exercise being reliable, the information alone on training the call off in a new and different way is worth the price of the book hands down. Order your copy by clicking hereclicking here.

Contact Jerry Bradshaw

Request product info from top K9 Police Training companies

Thank You!

= required Error occured while sending data

By submitting your information, you agree to be contacted by the selected vendor(s).
  1. Tags
  2. K-9

Join the discussion

logo for print