logo for print

Investigating crime in rural areas


Deputy Gary Nichols has worked in Moffat County, Colorado for 28 years. In January 2012 he won the Colorado Cattlemen’s Association Officer of the Year for 2011.

He received the recognition in part for his role, with strong support from State Brand Inspector Brad Ocker, in a months-long investigation of a local rancher that ended with a variety of cattle theft- related criminal charges and a financial cost to cattle owners of somewhere between $67,000 and $100,000 — numbers that equal some serious bank robberies.

The investigation spanned an area of 15,000 acres — 23 square miles, an area about the size of Boulder or Ann Arbor — of open range with nine different victims and covered incidents that occurred over a four-year period. In the course of the investigation he discovered twenty-nine re-branded cattle, which is similar to changing a vehicle’s VIN in an auto theft case.

On July 13, 2012, a jury found the defendant, Monty Pilgrim, guilty of five felony counts related to the thefts.

Deputy Nichols was also instrumental in preventing a statewide outbreak of a deadly parasitic disease, Equine Piroplasmosis. His investigation led to the discovery of five racehorses illegally transported into the U.S. from Mexico.

Had the disease spread local ranchers could have faced a staggering financial loss of livestock. Facing large fines and other costs the owner decided to euthanize the animals, effectively eliminating the disease from the area.

Outside of the investigation one of Deputy Nichols’ biggest challenges has been convincing local prosecutors and judges, who may have no knowledge of the livestock industry, of the seriousness of these types of offenses.

Recommended for you

Join the discussion

Copyright © 2017 PoliceOne.com. All rights reserved.