"Scan Patterns" next breakthrough in survival training?
II. FS News Reader Shares Feedback On Unintentional Discharges
III. L.A. Command Staff Briefed On Force Science Research Center Findings
I. "Scan Patterns": Next Breakthrough In Survival Training?
Do experienced, survival-savvy cops visually dissect and evaluate a potentially deadly scene differently than inexperienced or unaware officers or civilians?
Certainly seems logical…and now researchers are about to find out not only whether that's really true but also exactly how the best cops' eyes seek and track danger cues.
What they learn about the specifics of human "scan patterns" may significantly increase your survival odds by showing you how to detect and analyze lethal threats more efficiently, respond faster to protect yourself, and explain better in reports and in court why you took decisive defensive action.
"The rapid, accurate acquisition of information is the most important thing in a lethal-force encounter," says Dr. Bill Lewinski, executive director of the Force Science Research Center at Minnesota State University-Mankato. "We want to figure out how good cops get visual information and make good decisions. That undergirds everything. If you make wrong decisions--or no decision--because you're not picking up and properly interpreting important visual cues, that can have fatal consequences for you."
Lewinski became interested in scan patterns--the precise sequencing of eye movements made in taking in a field of view--because of research at Florida State University-Tallahassee on athletes and fighter pilots.
There Dr. Paul Ward found that highly skilled, elite athletes have a very different pattern of eye movements when surveying a field of play than do less-skilled, sub-elite athletes. That's apparently because their training and experience have taught them to look for and acknowledge certain behaviors in their opponents that, correctly interpreted, will help them anticipate and prepare for the flow of play.
"A good baseball batter begins to read a pitch very early from the way the pitcher's arm is working," Lewinski explains. "The batter is setting up his swing long before the ball crosses the plate, whereas the amateur may wait until the ball is coming at him and then it's too late to respond most effectively.
"The great hockey legend Wayne Gretski was known for his fast reactions and for always being in the right place at the right time. His father started taking him to arenas when he was very young and taught him to track the players and the puck on the ice. He learned to see and interpret patterns that allowed him to anticipate the action."
An intriguing aspect of Ward's work is that elite athletes, in addition to responding better, also remember more of an event--particularly those elements connected to their actions--than do non-elite athletes.
A colleague of Ward's, Dr. K. Anders Ericsson, found in studying outstanding Swedish fighter pilots that they, too, had visual scan patterns that differed from less experienced flyers.
"We suspect that the same is true among police officers," says Lewinski. "We want first to document the scan patterns of seasoned officers, of rookies and of civilians as they view short, dynamic, rapidly unfolding situations. Once these differences are understood, we hope to develop ways to teach officers the best scan patterns for assessing people and places so they get better at reading situations and more clearly and quickly see, evaluate and respond appropriately to lethal threats."
In a collaborative project now getting underway with Ward and Ericsson, a team of firearms trainers and police attorneys assembled by FSRC first will analyze multiple deadly force training scenarios supplied by the IES Interactive Training company of Littleton, CO. They will study and catalog body movements and other visual cues as each incident unfolds, identifying indicators that a threat is potentially present, when it becomes imminent and when it becomes immediate.
The Florida researchers then will show the scenarios on IES's Rangemaster simulator to a representative sampling of officers and civilians and track their scan patterns with the help of special optical equipment. They'll determine what skilled officers look at and in what sequence in order to quickly pick up on the danger signs, compared to the scan patterns of subjects who miss or misinterpret what is happening.
The findings should have important survival implications, particularly if successful scan patterning can be "blueprinted" and taught to others. "Scan patterns undoubtedly affect reaction time and the quality of response," Lewinski believes. "The more efficient you are in looking for and recognizing potential or unfolding threats, the more time you have for decision-making and reacting."
There also could be significant legal consequences. "Many times after violent encounters the reports of civilian witnesses about what happened are vastly different than what officers saw and reacted to," Lewinski says. "Their respective scan patterns may well be an important factor. Officers simply see things that civilians don't, and see their implications differently.
"If this can be documented and explained, it could help counter the suspicion that an officer is lying about perceived threats when stories conflict. We'll be able to explain in objective terms how and why people see different things in the same situation."
Preliminary results are expected as early as next spring, with a detailed analysis of the research probably available by next summer.
Once the scan phenomenon is researched, more work will need to be done to determine how much of quality performance is due to natural ability and how much can be influenced by training, Lewinski says. The FSRC will collaborate with IES and with LaserMax Inc. of Rochester, NY on the research.
II. A Reader Writes About Unintentional Discharges:
Bob Bragg, a Program Manager for Fitness and Force Training at the Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission, comments on the 10/15/04 Transmission about unintentional discharges:
"Tom Aveni [FSRC national advisory board member] asserts that it's his experience as a trainer that officers more often unconsciously put their finger inside the trigger guard when they are under potential threat conditions in dark surroundings.
"This has been confirmed via clinical research from the Naval Warfare Center in Florida, according to a researcher I spoke with there, Dr. Tom Franz. While it was not the intent of the research project, this phenomenon was clearly confirmed by the specialized equipment used."
III. LAPD Command Staff Briefed On Fsrc FSRC Findings:
Future deadly force encounters experienced by deputies from the Los Angeles Sheriff's Dept. will likely be more knowledgeably evaluated, thanks to two recent presentations there by Dr. Bill Lewinski, executive director of the Force Science Research Center.
In a special 4-hour program October 21, Lewinski briefed members of the agency's command staff on the Force Science Research Center's latest street-related findings. These included explanations of how conscientious officers can unwittingly set themselves up for unintentional discharges, how well-trained officers making lawful shooting decisions can sometimes end up shooting suspects in the back by, why officers often uncontrollably continue to fire "extra" rounds after a threat has ended, how traumatic events can play tricks with an officer's memory, and much more.
Last summer, Lewinski was invited to make a similar presentation to an audience of civil review board members, prosecutors and civil defense attorneys, homicide and I.A. investigators and others responsible for training and assessing the use of lethal force by LASD personnel.
"If these things are not fully understood, investigators, reviewers and administrators can easily jump to erroneous conclusions about a shooting," Lewinski explains, "and innocent officers can end up wrongfully accused of misdeeds that can destroy them."
For a full-length account of the content Lewinski covered and reactions to it, see the November/December issue of The Police Marksman magazine, due to be in the mail by November 7 (visit www.policemarksman.com for more information).
Recommended for you
Join the discussion
PoliceOne top 5
- DC cops' body cams won't be on while they monitor inauguration demonstrators
- Slain Fla. officer's cuffs used to arrest suspect
- Pa. cop sues Wal-Mart over termination for carrying gun on duty
- Video: Alleged Fla. cop killer refuses lawyer, shouts profanities in court
- Details emerge in shooting of Ariz. trooper by driver he sought to help